Timeshare Users Group Bulletin Boards
  Buying, Selling, Renting
  Timeshare vs Second Home (Page 1)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | bbs help (faq) | search |

BBS Home > Buying, Selling, Renting
This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Timeshare vs Second Home
jcopelk418

TUG Member

Posts: 111
From: knoxville,tennesseee
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-25-2005 16:25     Click Here to See the Profile for jcopelk418   Click Here to Email jcopelk418     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
In the eighties,I bought a condo as a vacation home.Over time I found the expense of maintaining it and trying to rent it very burdensome. I got rid of it after a few years and four years ago bought some timeshares as an alternative.I have been very pleased.
I wonder if there are others that have bought timeshare as an alternative to a second home.Are you pleased with your decision or miss having "your own place". I like the idea of handing someone the key and forgetting it till next time.One house for me is more than enough to take care of.Are some of you moving in the other direction?You are just waiting to ditch the timeshare till you can get the condo.

IP: Logged

BocaBum99

TUG Member

Posts: 1599
From:
Registered: Jul 2004

posted 05-25-2005 16:36     Click Here to See the Profile for BocaBum99   Click Here to Email BocaBum99     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I was looking at beach condos for a second home until I discovered timeshares. Now, I use them all the time. The flexibility is phenomenal. And, the deals are great.

I really do believe that timesharing is a continuing wave of the future as a real alternative to a second home.

IP: Logged

timeos2
Moderator
TUG Volunteer

Posts: 2029
From: Rochester, NY : Cypress Pointe & Westgate VV, Orlando Fl;FF Kingsgate Williamsburg, VA(FF Pts);Cove @ Yarmouth, Cape Cod MA;Rayburn CC, TX-RCI Pts
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-25-2005 17:02     Click Here to See the Profile for timeos2   Click Here to Email timeos2     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
As a family that formerly owned a cottage we loved I can say there is no comparison. That cottage cost us annual taxes, had to be maintained, had only 10-20 weeks a year of primary use yet demanded year round care and insurance. When we rented it we worried about damage and payment and our time there wasn't 100% vacation but 50% or more work to keep it up. Add in furnishings, cable service, appliances for a second full home - it was an expensive and time consuming project yet we hated to part with it. But after decades the family finally tired of feeling we had to return to our place and sold.

Enter timeshares. Less to buy, less to maintain and the location can be fixed as our Cape Cod summer week is as we enjoy every visit or float as our Orlando unit is so we can vary when we use it. Then we have our points that let us travel virtually anywhere at will. Cost? Not even 10% of the cottage but lacking in the the possible capital gain. I'll take the lower cost and flexibility even though I'll never regret all those years of memories at the cottage. My daughter considers our timeshares as her summer and holiday homes so the tradition continues. But at a much lower cost in areas we never could have seen if we still had to maintain that cottage by the bay.

------------------
John Chase
Use Email Icon above for contact address

[This message has been edited by timeos2 (edited 05-25-2005).]

IP: Logged

huestous

TUG Member

Posts: 146
From: Rochester, NY
Registered: Aug 2003

posted 05-25-2005 17:52     Click Here to See the Profile for huestous   Click Here to Email huestous     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We will be retiring in 5 years and are currently purchasing timeshares for this purpose. I've known a good many individuals with 2nd homes, and to a person their story echoes the comments made by John, above.

If I can "do it like Ray", I'll be quite happy with travel in retirement.

IP: Logged

reddiablosv

TUG Member

Posts: 294
From: Riverside, CA. USA
Registered: Oct 2003

posted 05-25-2005 18:55     Click Here to See the Profile for reddiablosv   Click Here to Email reddiablosv     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I just returned from a week at the Pahio at the Shearwater. It is a very nice resort with a wonderful view. While in Kauai I priced out what a comprable full time use condo would cost to purchase as a vacation residence. The best that I can determine is that the lising price would be well in excess of 1 million dollars!!! I used my Australian based points to exchange for the Shearwater. My cost for the points TS was $2250 with an annual MF of less than $600, and I still have 11K points left over. $2250 X 52 weeks is $117K. Not too long ago a TS week unit at the Shearwater sold on ebay for about $5800. $5800 X 52 is $301.6K. No matter how I look at it, if you buy a good resale TS at a good price, you come out ahead and can enjoy properties that few full time owners could afford. IMHO Ben.

[This message has been edited by reddiablosv (edited 05-25-2005).]

[This message has been edited by reddiablosv (edited 05-25-2005).]

IP: Logged

PA

TUG Member

Posts: 4004
From: San Antonio, TX 78258
Registered: Mar 2002

posted 05-25-2005 19:00     Click Here to See the Profile for PA   Click Here to Email PA     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I've owned 3 Lake Houses. Due to my flexible schedule, we were able to use them more than most people. We kept our ski boat there, and went most weekends in the summertime, plus stayed throughout the week many times. The first one we never rented. The second we rented every time we could, and made good money. The third we only rented during feb/mar when we didn't use it. Snowbirds used it, and paid almost 8 months of our mortgage during those 2 months.

So we loved our lake houses, and had great fun. But, they are expensive. The down side to timeshares is you can't leave your boat and your stuff there, and come/go as you please. Everything has pros and cons.

IP: Logged

Tacoma

TUG Member

Posts: 26
From: Calgary, Canada
Registered: Jan 2005

posted 05-25-2005 21:04     Click Here to See the Profile for Tacoma   Click Here to Email Tacoma     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I always wanted a vacation home but realistically knew it wasn't going to happen. So we found a trailer park on a lake in British Columbia which gives us the cottage experience for the cost most pay for taxes and utilities. THe kids love it as they have friends there to reconnect with every summer. Recently bought 2 timeshare weeks and am totally enjoying staying and trading. Have not joined an exchange company yet but eventually will probably have to to keep getting great trades. All vacations are wonderful when the kids were really little having a set place was way less stressful. Now that they are a little older we combine the two. Someday it may only be timeshares. The point is have fun whatever you choose.

Joan

------------------
Just Joan

IP: Logged

monica

TUG Member

Posts: 870
From: Houston, TX PB Sunset Beach-Cabo; Mayan Palace (5); Omni-Cancun; Krystal-PVR; FF Points; Melia Playa Conchal-Costa Rica; Allegro-Cancun
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-25-2005 21:40     Click Here to See the Profile for monica   Click Here to Email monica     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I'm moving in the timeshare direction. I've always wanted to have a 2nd home in Mexico for when I retire. Sounded like a great idea, what with the inexpensive way of life, right. Then I started spending all my vacation time there. Starting figuring out that Mexico has a very, very different way of doing things and getting things done than here in the US. So much red tape, bribes, and corruption. I've decided forget the 2nd home. Just timeshare it. We now own enough Mayan Palace's where we can spend almost 3 months a year there. We'll pick up a few more weeks later on. The maintenance fees are some of the lowest for the great product you get. We spend all our vacation time in Acapulco at this point in our lives. Later on when we retire, no insurance, taxes, utilities, cable, telephone, security bills; but have fantastic amenties such as beach, pool, golf, tennis, spa, medical, etc., including 2-times-a-day maid service. I'll just bring a few pictures of the family to put on the dresser! I'll never have the financial freedom necessary to retire in a place that is safe on the beach (too expensive for the upkeep once you own it), so this is the alternative I'm working towards. And if I want to go on a vacation from Acapulco, the Mayan Palace has other locations I can visit.

IP: Logged

AwayWeGo

TUG Member

Posts: 1161
From: McLean, Virginia. Own at Cypress Pointe II (Orlando) & Lowveld Lodge (White River, South Africa)
Registered: May 2002

posted 05-25-2005 21:46     Click Here to See the Profile for AwayWeGo   Click Here to Email AwayWeGo     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We used to have an attractive, modern, spacious, well equipped, nicely furnished 3BR-2BA double-wide mobile home on rented ground in a nice park right near Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. Didn't pay much for it -- $33,000 or so -- but we had to pay the ground rent, phone bill & electric bill every month, plus a hefty sewer bill quarterly. There might have been taxes, too -- I don't remember. Plus, we had to pay the lawn mowing service since we didn't go there frequently enough to keep the grass neatly cut & trimmed.

But for as little as we stayed there, it was way too costly. So after a couple of years we sold the double-wide for $35,000 or so, which (after sales commissions) means we came short of breaking even, not even counting all those monthly & quarterly costs.

Now we have a dinky 34-foot travel trailer on a site in a nice park right next to the park where we formerly had our double-wide. It's a seasonal park, not year-round. The park turns the water on the end of April & shuts it off the end of October. Annual rent for the season = $800. (That includes water & sewer.) Our used ("resale") 1999 CoachMen trailer cost us about $11,000 (eBay). For propane & electric power, per season, we pay about $110. We mow our own postage-stamp-size "lawn."

We go to the trailer slightly oftener than we used to go to the double-wide & we have just about as much fun when we go -- without feeling we've laid out too much money for too little use.

On top of that, thanks to TUG, we got ourselves a top-quality, luxurious, spacious 3BR Floating Diamond lock-off timeshare in Orlando FL that we like to go to (& so do our son & daughter-in-law) -- so much so that we never deposit it for exchange, just use it ourselves within the family.

We got the timeshare used ("resale") via eBay for nickels on the dollar. Even paying the annual fees, reserves, & taxes, it's an extravagant place to stay without running up extravagant costs -- a luxury vacation condo at the approximate cost of a hotel or motel.

The Orlando timeshare worked out so well that -- also thanks to TUG -- we took the South African timeshare plunge, acquiring a 2BR fixed red week at minimal cost that (so far) has been good for exchanges into nice USA timeshare resorts at times that suit our travel plans.

In all, with the dinky trailer & the 2 timeshares, we have as many vacation travel opportunities as we want to use. If we desire more in the future, I have an idea we will start looking once again into timeshare "points" -- but that's another story.

-- Alan Cole, McLean (Fairfax County), Virginia, USA.

------------------
Through the sycamores the Cadillacs are gleaming, and the bankers on the Wabash shout Hooray! -BRC.

IP: Logged

Judy

TUG Member

Posts: 1960
From: Melbourne Beach, FL & Steamboat Springs CO. owner: Celebrity Resort World of Orlando; The Ridge Tahoe; Hatteras High; Worldmark. member:II,RCI,DAE,SFX
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-26-2005 05:53     Click Here to See the Profile for Judy   Click Here to Email Judy     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
Both timeshares and a second home
Our timeshares led us to our second home. We booked into Worldmark Steamboat Springs two years in a row and liked it so much that we wanted to spend the whole ski season there when we retired. We discovered that we could buy a whole-ownership condo and maintain it for less than 16 weeks of timeshare, even on the resale market. Before we retired, we tried renting the condo. It cost more in money and aggrevation than it paid. I wouldn't recommend renting out a second home unless you're handy, can rent it without an agent, and live nearby.
Once we retired, we took the condo out of the rental market. It's very convenient. We have a good HOA with a reliable manager. If there's a problem while we've away, we just call him and he takes care of it. We leave our winter clothing and ski stuff in Colorado. We leave our summer clothing and beach stuff in Florida.
In between beach and ski season, we use our timeshares to go diving and otherwise see the world. The only downside to the timeshares have been RCI and II's VEP restrictions that cause me more aggrevation than both of our homes put together.
Of course that could change. It's only 6 days until hurricane season

IP: Logged

LeAnn Thom

TUG Member

Posts: 164
From: Edam,SK,Canada
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-26-2005 05:57     Click Here to See the Profile for LeAnn Thom   Click Here to Email LeAnn Thom     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
My family owned a small house at the coast, and every weekend we made the trip to our second home. My father went fishing, the kids played (and went fishing) and my mum worked in the beautiful yard. And worked, and worked (she loved yardwork). Didn't have to cook though (she didn't like cooking) because my father always took the family out one night for supper, and just the two of them went out on the other. They both seemed quite happy with the arrangement.

I loved that place, have fantastic memories, and agree that when the kids are little it is the best way to go. As time went on and I grew up, I realized that I didn't want to have a "second home" because then you are tied to using it for all of your holidays (and there is no end to the work). Well, you have invested all that money right? Why spend even more traveling someplace when you already have a cabin?

When my husband started making noises about a cabin at the lake, I remembered that feeling of obligation to spend all free time there and said I didn't think that it was a great idea.

Enter timesharing! Besides the variety of the locations and the luxury of the accomodations, that investment thing STILL makes you feel obligated to use it. I consider that to be one of the best aspects of a timeshare purchase - it MAKES you take your holiday time, just like that second home does. Otherwise, there are always too many other distractions in life (like work?) that keep getting in the way.

For different stages of our lives and/or different desires in a vacation, each makes sense. But, if you like to travel, I vote for timesharing!

LeAnn

[This message has been edited by LeAnn Thom (edited 05-26-2005).]

IP: Logged

Ray

TUG Member

Posts: 1327
From: Cape Cod. Own: Marathon Key, LaCosta, Inn on Harbor, HarwichPort, Marriott Vail Birch
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-26-2005 06:44     Click Here to See the Profile for Ray   Click Here to Email Ray     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
John,
Darlene and I enjoy our Cape Cod condo for the warm six months each year and we also enjoy living in timeshares for six months each year. We own thirteen timeshare weeks which we exchange every year. RCI and II promotions enable us to cover the other six months in timeshares, mostly in Florida.
I hope you are able to work out a similar arrangement that meets your needs.
Ray

IP: Logged

geekette

Non Member

Posts: 291
From:
Registered: Sep 2004

posted 05-26-2005 07:47     Click Here to See the Profile for geekette   Click Here to Email geekette     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
quote:
Originally posted by LeAnn Thom:
[B]... Besides the variety of the locations and the luxury of the accomodations, that investment thing STILL makes you feel obligated to use it. I consider that to be one of the best aspects of a timeshare purchase - it MAKES you take your holiday time, just like that second home does. Otherwise, there are always too many other distractions in life (like work?) that keep getting in the way.
...
.B]

No second home for us - the first is an older home and plenty of work. I used to think it'd be great to own rental properties, but after seeing the hassles a friend of mine went thru, and then owning our current home, No Way.

Being "forced" to vacation works great for us. I'm not sure we'd be travelling much if we didn't have the Use It Or Lose It attached. I would want to, but hubby would always object with "it's too expensive!" Piddly exchange fee changes the game greatly. Staying in our home resort network even removes that expense.

IP: Logged

Gramma4

TUG Member

Posts: 376
From: Minneapolis,MN;
Registered: Nov 2001

posted 05-26-2005 08:12     Click Here to See the Profile for Gramma4   Click Here to Email Gramma4     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We do own a second townhome on the West coast of Fl. We also own 2 t/s weeks that we use to trade into Breezy Point,MN each summer for a family vacation with grandkids.
When we downsized we purchased a townhome here in MN and also one in Fl. (for future retirement). We seasonally rent out the townhome in Fl. on VRBO.com and it has been very easy and covers our expenses plus(condo is paid for tho). We use the condo in April and Oct. and occasionally family will go at other times. We will retire in 3-4 years and look forward to spending the winters there. It has worked for us because we were able to purchase the Fl. townhome with excess funds from the sale of our home. We love having the option for using both. We will use the t/s for future vacations after we retire.
It is getting very difficult to purchase the second homes in Fl. now with the increases in real estate. We were very fortunate to be able to do this 7 years ago!

IP: Logged

Gramma4

TUG Member

Posts: 376
From: Minneapolis,MN;
Registered: Nov 2001

posted 05-26-2005 08:15     Click Here to See the Profile for Gramma4   Click Here to Email Gramma4     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We do own a second townhome on the West coast of Fl. We also own 2 t/s weeks that we use to trade into Breezy Point,MN each summer for a family vacation with grandkids.
When we downsized we purchased a townhome here in MN and also one in Fl. (for future retirement). We seasonally rent out the townhome in Fl. on VRBO.com and it has been very easy and covers our expenses plus(condo is paid for tho). We use the condo in April and Oct. and occasionally family will go at other times. We will retire in 3-4 years and look forward to spending the winters there. It has worked for us because we were able to purchase the Fl. townhome with excess funds from the sale of our home. We love having the option for using both. We will use the t/s for future vacations after we retire.
It is getting very difficult to purchase the second homes in Fl. now with the increases in real estate. We were very fortunate to be able to do this 7 years ago!

IP: Logged

Maz

TUG Member

Posts: 2804
From: Scottsdale,Arizona
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-26-2005 10:21     Click Here to See the Profile for Maz   Click Here to Email Maz     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
Owning second homes is either the best thing in the world or the worse thing...For us it has been fantastic!

We now own 3 second homes in Mexico and its been great! We bought the original one as a second home with no intentions of renting. We just wanted to own a home on the beach. To this day, we never rent this one.

We then bought another one and use soley as a rental. It is rented around 80% of the year as vacation rentals and very profitable. We have to turn away rentals quite often as we are full. Because of this, we bought another one which will be done in July. When we move into that one, we will turn the original one that we are moving out of into a second rental.

The way I see it, if you can own a second home that brings in thousands of dollars in profit every year along with the fact that you can use it, it is a great way to go.Especially if they are seeing a lot of appreciation. It just depends on the exact situation. If you are going to own a second home home that sits empty and just costs you money, its a bad idea. Kind of like timeshares Maz

------------------
My Website
Marriott-Canyon Villas
Marriott-Park City
Fairfield-Points
Worldmark-Trendwest
Oregon-Coastal
Rancho Banderas-Mx.
Punta Mita-Mx.(Non-Timeshare)

IP: Logged

jcopelk418

TUG Member

Posts: 111
From: knoxville,tennesseee
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-28-2005 19:21     Click Here to See the Profile for jcopelk418   Click Here to Email jcopelk418     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I think the discussion shows there is no right answer for everyone.It seems that there is general agreement that a person has to give some thought to how they will use their second home or timeshare and the cost.
I wanted to be able to use six weeks or so in January or Febuary in south Florida or Arizona or California and have one or two extra weeks. Buying a couple of Marriott Ocean Pointe Platinum lockoffs and several Marriott silver seasons have worked for me.I normally use the Ocean Points which are located in south Florida and have been successful trading into other warm weather locations to get my six weeks.Using acc. certificates plus the properties I own,the plan is working well for me.
From the comments,it seems a second home becomes a very viable option to those who will use it a lot, and/or can turn their property into an income producer through their own management or through a good property manager.In the areas I am interested in, I do not think buying a condo for six or eight weeks use is economically sound. It is clear that Maz and others have found areas where ownership makes sense even from an economic standpoint.Most would agree that they are probably not located in south Florida or southern California.
Thanks to all for their imput.

IP: Logged

rapmarks

TUG Member

Posts: 1926
From: Estero, FL and Wisconsin Dells, WI
Registered: Apr 2002

posted 05-29-2005 07:21     Click Here to See the Profile for rapmarks   Click Here to Email rapmarks     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We have owned a second home since 1988. We do not rent it out. We made sure it was low maintenance. We have never had any regrets. We also own 3 weeks of timeshare. After we retired, we would spend 14 weeks a year in timeshares, mostly using it as a base to find a winter home. While it is doable, it is nowhere near the same as having your own place. Plus you have a more substantive life style in your own community. Don't forget that Ray stays in timeshares near his family, and has frequent visits with them. We do run into people who own 8 or 12 weeks in t he same resort. They have made friends with people who are there year after year.
We were able to find a free standing home in Florida where the outside maintenance is totally taken care of. Our home has probably doubled in value in the year and a half we have owned it. Also, we figure the savings in state income taxes versus Wisconsin pays for the taxes, insurance, maintenace fees and utilities. The majority of our neighbors have two homes also and also many of them have timeshares, some of them a half hour away from where we live.

------------------
rapmarks

IP: Logged

OCsun

TUG Member

Posts: 239
From: Forest Hill, MD
Registered: May 2003

posted 05-29-2005 14:05     Click Here to See the Profile for OCsun     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We too own both!
Back in the early 80's when I was young and broke with big ideas. . . .I borrowed money from credit cards to put a down payment on a property in Ocean City, MD. Since I was never a big saver, it turned out to be the best investment I ever made.
I paid the property off prior to my retirement four years ago.

Since it is within a three hour drive of our home, frequent trips to the ocean provided R&R getaways over the years. The money we invested, thanks to the value of beach front property on the east coast, is now my extra retirement cushion, if the need arises. The annual expenses I incur are easily taken care of with a few weeks rental.

Over the years, I did make payments and spend time painting, cleaning and decorating my vacation home. For me, the pride of ownership was a dream fulfilled. I can now spend summers at the beach, a thought I would day dream, for many years.

Timeshare's however, are my new love. Because as much as I love summers at the beach, I love flying out of the snow in the winter. We own two timeshares and are working on a third.

I now dream of owning 6 straight weeks in a nice warm climate. However, since I have a rule that I only buy timeshares if I have the money . . . they are a little slower coming. I am not sure about age making me wiser but I do know it has made me more frugal.

IP: Logged

Larry

TUG Member

Posts: 784
From: Long Island, NY - Playa Linda, Aruba wks 51& 11.Aruba Renaissance wk 2 St. Marteen, Pelican wks 50 & 51. Jockey Club, Vegas, wk 8 - Flagship AC
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-30-2005 09:05     Click Here to See the Profile for Larry   Click Here to Email Larry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
quote:
Originally posted by Maz:
Owning second homes is either the best thing in the world or the worse thing...For us it has been fantastic!

We now own 3 second homes in Mexico and its been great! We bought the original one as a second home with no intentions of renting. We just wanted to own a home on the beach. To this day, we never rent this one.

We then bought another one and use soley as a rental. It is rented around 80% of the year as vacation rentals and very profitable. We have to turn away rentals quite often as we are full. Because of this, we bought another one which will be done in July. When we move into that one, we will turn the original one that we are moving out of into a second rental.

The way I see it, if you can own a second home that brings in thousands of dollars in profit every year along with the fact that you can use it, it is a great way to go.Especially if they are seeing a lot of appreciation. It just depends on the exact situation. If you are going to own a second home home that sits empty and just costs you money, its a bad idea. Kind of like timeshares Maz


Wow Maz you are my hero!!!!

I knew that you owned a condo in Punta Mita but didn't know you owned three in Mexico. Where else do you own in Mexico?

I thought I was good since we now own seven timeshares weeks and rent out 3 weeks. We were able to rent our three weeks for over $3,600 and our maintenance on seven weeks is about $3,200 so we now vacation 4 weeks a year for free including exchaange fees and II and RCI memberships.

If I knew I could buy some vacation condo's and rent them out for a profit I would certainly do that as well but probably wouldn't have the guts to buy them outside of the USA.

------------------
Larry

IP: Logged

Steve Barr

TUG Member

Posts: 446
From: Raleigh, NC USA
Registered: Jan 2001

posted 05-30-2005 18:33     Click Here to See the Profile for Steve Barr   Click Here to Email Steve Barr     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We live in NC and enjoy the beach. We were very close to a beachfront condo purchase 5-6 years ago, while we were considering it, a hurricane took the development out (literally).

We own 10 t/s. 8 in Daytona, 1 in Atlantic Beach, NC and one 1 n Banner Elk, NC. We use 6 each year and rent the other 4 out each year (usually to the same people). Our rentals cover about 80% of the mf + taxes on all 10.

So, we have 5 beachfront weeks and one mountain week each year at prime times for our own use, my 'out of pocket' mf + taxes after rentals are around $1000 and my total purchase costs were well under $20k total for all of them. For us, owning a beachfront place with the hassles makes no sense. Granted, there is no real appreciation in the timeshares like there is on beachfront property.

------------------
Steve H. Barr
Raleigh, NC

Assorted summer Daytona and North Carolina beach weeks.

It's o.k. if you disagree with me, I fully respect your right to be wrong.

IP: Logged

elaine

TUG Member

Posts: 570
From: washington, DC
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-30-2005 19:34     Click Here to See the Profile for elaine   Click Here to Email elaine     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
I raised a similar issue a few weeks ago. With the sky-high prices of mid-atlantic beach properties, and the still depressed price of resale TS--the economics are definitely there to do "serial" TS instead of buying real estate. I could buy 4-5 summer weeks of TS for about $2500 each with maint. fees of $500 each---given that I can most likely resell a summer beach TS, the $2500 is more like a deposit for each. If I wanted a month at the beach each year---that is what I would do.

IP: Logged

abelee

TUG Member

Posts: 413
From: Upstate New York, USA
Registered: Sep 2001

posted 05-31-2005 08:48     Click Here to See the Profile for abelee   Click Here to Email abelee     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
Can (do) resorts limit the number of consecutive weeks a guest can stay at their facility? If one is using the reservations as a "second home" experience, what are the limitations, if any?

[This message has been edited by abelee (edited 05-31-2005).]

IP: Logged

Dori

TUG Member

Posts: 1059
From: Scarborough, Ontario, Canada , Owner at Harbour Inn and Resort Club, Brechin, Ontario and a Lowveld week
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-31-2005 17:56     Click Here to See the Profile for Dori   Click Here to Email Dori     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
We have owned our timeshares for 13 years and have had (and continue to have) wonderful vacations, making the most of our weeks. Three years ago, we bought a cottage. All I can say is."Give me my timeshare vacations!!!" Cottages are too much work!

Dori

IP: Logged

Maz

TUG Member

Posts: 2804
From: Scottsdale,Arizona
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 06-01-2005 09:05     Click Here to See the Profile for Maz   Click Here to Email Maz     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote Post A Reply
quote:
Originally posted by Larry:
Wow Maz you are my hero!!!!

I knew that you owned a condo in Punta Mita but didn't know you owned three in Mexico. Where else do you own in Mexico?

If I knew I could buy some vacation condo's and rent them out for a profit I would certainly do that as well but probably wouldn't have the guts to buy them outside of the USA.



Larry,

We own all 3 in Punta Mita...As a matter of fact, we just arrived here last night after the 2 day drive from Scottsdale. We normally fly as it is only a 2 hour non stop flight but in the summer we are here for 3 months straight and the airlines kill ya on fares if you stay over 30 days. Plus...We like the chance to get larger items down here. Last here it was a new stove and plasma tv..This year it was a double oven and dishwasher etc (for the new place)...

Ya, its funny...We bought the first one as a second beach home. Bought the second one because we wanted to try the rental thing. First year the rental was rented out almost 80% of the weeks of the year (weekly rentals) and this year we are pacing even higher! The rental brings in approx $40,000 a year in rental income but with rising rents in the area (Punta Mita) that should improve. This year we are way ahead of last year in the way of rentals...

The nice thing about Mexico is the hired help is so affordable. We have a full time lady who does everything from cleaning the condo before and after rentals to daily maid service. We pay her almost $5000 USD a year and that includes the 8 hours a day she works for us when we are there 4 months out of the year.My neighbors give me guff for over-paying her but we dont mind as she has been with us for 4 years now and is like family.


She cleans every day and is our baby sitter. She has been baby sitting for our 3 1/2 year old daughter since she was born so they have a real bond. She only speaks spanish and we like it that way as we get tons of practice . Its cool seeing our daughter learning spanish at such a young age.
When our 3rd condo is finished and we move in, our 2nd condo will become a second rental and she will have her hands full. Mexico is a great place to own a second home if you want rental income as it rents year round. Places like Cape Cod etc have a very short rental window.

Anyway..In summary, I can only say that owning second homes in Mexico has been one of the best things we have ever done not just from a financial sense but also a life sense. I highly recommend it if you like beaches and want rental income. The bonus is that the people are absolutely fantastic down here. Maz

------------------
My Website
Marriott-Canyon Villas
Marriott-Park City
Fairfield-Points
Worldmark-Trendwest
Oregon-Coastal
Rancho Banderas-Mx.
Punta Mita-Mx.(Non-Timeshare)

IP: Logged


This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 

All times are in Pacific Timezone

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | TUG Home | Privacy Statement

Copyright Timeshare User's Group - BBS Script customized by Laurence Chan lcc_home@hotmail.com
The Timeshare Users Group (TUG) makes no representations or warranties with respect to the use of the TUG bulletin boards, or their contents and further makes no representations with respect to the results that may be obtained from information on the BBS. The Timeshare Users Group shall not be liable for any damage or loss of any type arising from such use or content, and reserves the right to remove any posting on the bulletin boards. The bulletin boards are intended for use by Timeshare Users Group members, Non member postings are welcome. Advertising is not permitted on the BBS, TUG provides other areas on this web site for advertising. Any messages that are deemed as advertising will be deleted. Please read the full TUG BBS Usage agreement located in the FAQ. By using the BBS you accept and agree with the above statements. If you do not agree please return to the TUG Home Page

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47a